5:40am

Sat December 22, 2012
U.S.

Immigrants Welcomed: A City Sees Economic Promise

Originally published on Wed December 26, 2012 11:40 am

If there's one common language that some recent immigrants in Dayton, Ohio, seem to share, it's soccer.

The first Dayton World Soccer Games kicked off earlier this year, an initiative hosted by the city to welcome an influx of immigrants. On the field, a rainbow of brightly colored jerseys represented nearly 20 of the different immigrant communities in the city.

"I've been really surprised to see that there's a lot of soccer going on in Dayton," says Adolphe Bizwinayo, who left Rwanda as a refugee.

The sport, he says, has been instrumental in his transition to the unfamiliar city.

"It just brings this joy, like we are home ... like how we used to play soccer back at home when we would play for hours and hours," Bizwinayo says.

That kind of response is exactly why the city launched Welcome Dayton last year — a strategy to help immigrants ease into American life. City Manager Tim Riordan credits two reasons for the adopted framework: It was the right thing to do, he says, and immigrants were needed to help restore the battered city's economy.

"I saw immigrants doing things in the neighborhoods," Riordan says. "They were buying really inexpensive houses and fixing them up. I heard stories from hardware owners where the immigrants would come and buy one window at a time to fix up their house as they got money."

An Investment In The Community

Riordan says changing Dayton's culture is an investment in the city. One section of the city, for example, is now entirely designated as an immigrant business zone, and police can check immigration statuses only when suspicious of a serious crime.

Audrey Singer, a senior fellow at the Brookings Metropolitan Policy Program, says the relationship between cities and immigrants is certainly evolving.

"What's good about the Dayton program is the way that leaders in those communities talk about immigrants and talk about them as a positive force and contributing," she says.

In fact, a Brookings study finds that immigrants are 30 percent more likely to form new businesses than U.S.-born citizens, which is good news for a city like Dayton, which has been bleeding jobs and population for decades.

Legal Immigrants, That Is

Not everyone, however, is a fan of the city's new approach. Steve Salvi runs the Cleveland-based Ohio Jobs and Justice PAC, a group focused on illegal immigration. He says officials are relying on a naive myth that immigrants will be the saviors of Dayton.

"I think what the city needs to do is focus on helping native residents and make the city a place where people want to come and start a business if they're immigrants or native-born," Salvi says.

One of his largest concerns is that Dayton could become a sanctuary city, a place harboring illegal immigrants.

City Manager Riordan, however, maintains that the term immigrant is not synonymous with illegal. "Frankly, the good people of Dayton didn't have that kind of attitude," he says. "It was the people from outside of Dayton. I got emails from outside Wyoming and Montana telling us what to do, and I was like, 'Eh, that's not your business.' "

The real thrust of the plan focuses on legal immigrants, Riordan adds. For instance, the city wants to help people like Francis Matias, who worked hard to get his Puerto Rican restaurant, Antojitos, off the ground.

"In other states, it's harder. They're following immigrants and they're treated like criminals. Here, it's great," Matias says in his kitchen.

Other cities, however, are now falling into line with Dayton. Tucson, Ariz., and Salt Lake City, for example, are among those also making it official policy to welcome immigrants and help them feel at home.

Copyright 2013 WYSO-FM. To see more, visit http://www.wyso.org.

Transcript

SCOTT SIMON, HOST:

And while some groups, like Mr. Medina's, are pushing for greater acceptance of immigration, a coalition of civic, community and business leaders in Dayton, Ohio, is already embracing them. Last year, the city of Dayton declared itself as immigrant-friendly in hopes of stemming population loss and growing the economy. As Emily McCord of member station WYSO reports, it's an approach that's influencing the way other cities now deal with immigration.

UNIDENTIFIED MAN: Defense, defense, defense. Come get the ball.

EMILY MCCORD, BYLINE: Apparently there's one common language that some recent immigrants to Dayton seem to share - soccer.

(SOUNDBITE OF CHEERING)

MCCORD: It's now been a year since the immigrant-friendly plan was adopted here, and real change comes slowly. But this mini World Cup event is a start. A rainbow of brightly colored jerseys dot the field here representing nearly 20 of the different immigrant communities in this city.

ADOLPHE BIZWINAYO: I've been really surprised to see that there are a lot of soccer going on around here in Dayton.

MCCORD: Adolphe Bizwinayo left Rwanda as a refugee. He says Dayton has helped him transition to American life and these World Soccer Games are playing an important role.

BIZWINAYO: Just bring this joy, like we are home, like how we used to play soccer back at home when we would play for hours and hours.

(APPLAUSE)

MCCORD: The so-called Welcome Dayton plan aims to make newcomers feel that way. When the framework was adopted, City Manager Tim Riordan says it was for two reasons. First, it was the right to do, and secondly, immigrants were needed to restore this battered cities' economy.

TIM RIORDAN: I saw immigrants doing things in the neighborhoods. They were buying really inexpensive houses and fixing them up. I heard stories from hardware owners where the immigrants would come and buy one window at a time to fix up their house as they got money.

MCCORD: Riordan says changing Dayton's culture is an investment in the city. For example, a section of town now is designated as an immigrant business zone. The plan also addresses law enforcement. Police now only check immigration status when there are suspicions of a serious crime.

AUDREY SINGER: We are seeing change.

MCCORD: Audrey Singer studies immigration at the Brookings Institution.

SINGER: What's good with the Dayton program is the way the leaders in those communities talk about immigrants and talk about them as a positive force and contributing.

MCCORD: In fact, a Brookings study finds that immigrants are 30 percent more likely to form new businesses than U.S.-born citizens. That's good news for a city like Dayton that's been bleeding jobs and population for decades. But not everyone thinks this open-arms approach is a good one. Steve Salvi runs the Cleveland-based Ohio Jobs and Justice PAC, a group focused on illegal immigration.

STEVE SALVI: The city is relying on this myth that immigrants are, you know, going to be the savior of Dayton. And I think what the city needs to do is focus on helping native residents and make the city a place where people want to come and start a business if they're immigrants or native born.

MCCORD: Salvi's concerned that Dayton could become a sanctuary city, a place harboring illegal immigrants. City Manager Tim Riordan says the term immigrant is not a synonym for illegal.

RIORDAN: Frankly, the good people of Dayton didn't have that kind of attitude. It was the people from outside of Dayton. I got emails from Wyoming and Montana telling us what to do. And it's, like, eh, it's not your business.

MCCORD: Besides, says Riordan, the real thrust of the plan is focus on legal immigrants, like Francis Matias.

FRANCIS MATIAS: Hello? Antojitos.

MCCORD: Antojitos restaurant serves Puerto Rican food. Matias says they have specialty dishes like Mofongo - plantains, which are fried and mashed.

MATIAS: We have all the seasonings here, and all the pork, the butter. And now he going to put the plantains in the mortar and start mashing.

MCCORD: Matias has worked hard to get his restaurant off the ground and is excited about Welcome Dayton. He thinks it makes it a little easier for people like him to start a business here. And that's different from other places.

MATIAS: In other states, it's harder. They're following immigrants. And they treated like criminals. Here, it's great.

MCCORD: But there are signs of change. Other cities are now adopting plans similar to Dayton's - cities like Tucson and Salt Lake City and others, who are making it official policy to welcome immigrants and help them feel at home. For NPR news, I'm Emily McCord.

(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC)

SIMON: And you're listening to WEEKEND EDITION from NPR News. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.