Why Heavy Teens May Eat Less But Weigh More Than Their Thinner Peers
Originally published on Wed September 19, 2012 4:08 pm
It may be more important than we thought to tackle obesity in childhood. A new study published in Pediatrics finds that overweight teenagers eat fewer calories than their healthy weight peers.
That's right — they eat less.
How much less? The study found that among 12- to 14-year-olds, obese girls consumed 110 fewer calories daily than healthy-weight girls. And overweight boys between the ages of 15 and 17 consumed about 375 fewer calories a day than healthy-weight boys.
Up to the ages of of 8 or 9, overweight children ate more calories than their slimmer peers. But, "at about age 9 or 10, we start to see, essentially, a flip," explains Skinner. Basically, heavier older kids start to eat less.
"One reason this makes sense is because we know overweight children are less active than healthy weight kids," explains lead researcher Asheley Cockrell Skinner of the University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill.
And obesity expert Matthew Gillman of the Harvard School of Public Health says the amount of physical activity kids participate in is key. "When you're less physically active, you actually need fewer calories to maintain your weight," he explains.
But if that weight is already higher than it should be, that could signal the beginning of a long-term problem.
"Once you become overweight, there are changes in your body that make you different from someone who's not [overweight]," explains Sophia Yen of Stanford School of Medicine. "You have extra fat cells, and you have different insulin levels," which can make it feel like you're eating less than you are.
"And once these effects have taken place, the fat deposition or the insulin changes in your body, then it's a lot harder to reverse," Yen tells The Salt.
Take fat cells, for instance. Once the body creates a fat cell, it lasts a lifetime.
"You can slim down that fat cell, but that fat cell will always be sitting there, waiting to be larger if you give it extra calories," she says.
So Yen's advice to parents of young children: If you see signs of a weight problem, it's better to take action sooner rather than later.
The findings of the new study are based on dietary reports collected from 19,125 children, from toddlers to teens, as part of the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (NHANES). The way the survey works is that participants report everything they've eaten in a 24-hour period, and researchers separately measure height and weight to calculate BMI (body mass index).
Now, because researchers are not able to verify diets that are self-reported, the study's findings have some major caveats. Yen and her Stanford colleagues have seen major errors using similar dietician recall methods. And they point out that overweight people tend to underreport what they're eating more than healthy weight people. More research is needed.
AUDIE CORNISH, HOST:
Why do children and teens become overweight? The answer to that question is not as straightforward as counting calories. NPR's Allison Aubrey has this story about a study published today in the journal Pediatrics. It suggests that the eating habits of overweight teens are not all that different from their healthy-weight peers.
ALLISON AUBREY, BYLINE: Physical activity comes easiest to the youngest of children. From soccer tots, to elementary school baseball teams, lots of kids are excited about sports at this age. And parents are often invested, too.
(SOUNDBITE OF CHILDREN PLAYING SPORTS)
AUBREY: But fast forward to the tween years, and chances are that many of these little athletes will have given up organized sports for more sedentary pursuits such as video gaming.
(SOUNDBITE OF VIDEO GAME)
AUBREY: About the only thing getting a workout here are the fingers. It may not seem like a big deal to replace an hour of soccer practice with an hour of video gaming, but small changes in physical activity lead to fewer burned calories. And researcher Ashley Skinner, of the University of North Carolina, was curious. Was this difference alone enough to make a kid overweight? What about the role of diet?
ASHLEY SKINNER: So the question was, well, I wonder what these kids are actually eating. Are they actually eating that much differently compared to healthy-weight kids?
AUBREY: To examine this, she and her colleagues studied the weight and diet of about 19,000 children from toddlers to teens, using information from a large federal survey. Skinner says, what she found was surprising. Up to the age of eight or nine, overweight kids were eating more calories than their healthy-weight peers. But as the tween years set in, the picture changed.
SKINNER: At about age nine or 10, we start to see essentially a flip. That the overweight kids are actually eating less than the healthy-weight ones.
AUBREY: The overweight kids are actually eating less?
SKINNER: Right. So they're actually taking in fewer calories than the healthy-weight kids.
AUBREY: Now, the researchers could not independently verify the amount kids said they were eating. So it's possible some were not accurate. But the findings were consistent. On average, heavy kids were eating about 100 fewer calories a day compared to their healthy-weight peers. Obesity expert Matthew Gilman of Harvard medical school says this isn't the first study to suggest that heavy teenagers don't necessarily eat more calories. And it supports the idea that small differences in physical activity do seem to be key.
MATTHEW GILMAN: When you're less physically active, you actually need fewer calories to maintain your weight.
AUBREY: And, on top of that...
GILMAN: You actually need fewer calories to increase your weight.
AUBREY: Skinner's findings also hint at the significance of being overweight at such a young age in the early elementary years. Sophia Yen is with Stanford medical school.
SOPHIA YEN: Once you've become overweight there are changes in your body that make you different from someone who's not. So you have extra fat cells, you have different insulin levels.
AUBREY: Which can make it feel like you're eating less than you are. And these changes, she explains, are very persistent.
YEN: And once the effects have taken place, you know, the fat deposition, or the insulin changes in your body, then it's a lot harder to reverse.
AUBREY: Yen says, the important message is that early life experiences can shape the trajectory for weight throughout life. Take for instance, fat cells. Once the body creates a fat cell, it never goes away.
YEN: You can slim down that fat cell, but that fat cell will always be there waiting to get larger if you give it any extra calories.
AUBREY: So Yen says, her advice to parents of young children is: if you see signs of a weight problem, it's better to take action sooner rather than later. Allison Aubrey, NPR News.
(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC) Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright National Public Radio.